This might be a difficult question. The reason being that Fantine, strictly speaking as a novel-bound character, is difficult to imagine in terms of appearance. According to what I have read, she is supposed to be 'youthfully attractive' and innocent-looking. Having said this, one must remember how her appearance must've changed after being driven to prostitution in her desperation to provide for her daughter. I, personally, have not seen enough portrayals of Fantine (I was about to write, "I have not seen enough Fantines," but that would have been objectifying the poor woman) to effectively say that I have a favorite (that sounds just as objectifying). In terms of vocals, Ruthie Henshall would have to be who I prefer listening to the most. She has that subtle edge of someone who remains incredibly strong in times of strife, yet still finds vulnerability in her innocence (despite her misfortunes). She also treads the thread between being admirable and being pitiful. One does not necessarily wish to be her (at least, I certainly hope not); rather, one wishes to be like her in courage and determination.
Though I prefer Henshall's portrayal of Fantine over other recordings, I don't like her appearance. This is not to say that Henshall is not pretty (on the contrary) but she just isn't how I imagined Fantine to look. Now, if we're going to include film actors as well as musical performers, then I would have to say my favorite Fantine (in terms of appearance) is Charlotte Gainsbourg, who was in the 2000 tv film.
In the beginning of this scene, she's taken her daughter Cosette to an innkeeper and his wife, who offer shelter and food for her, if Fantine pays a monthly sum. Desperate, she agrees, unaware that they will abuse and neglect Cosette. Making things all the more tragic.
Gah! Charlotte, why are you so beautiful??
Turns out, Gainsbourg is also a singer. Hmm.
No comments:
Post a Comment